The Green River
While the Green River, which runs through Utah, Wyoming, and Colorado, is only a tributary of the Colorado River, it has still become a major source of debate and controversy among the three states’ residents and lawmakers. The Green River starts in the Wind River Mountains in Wyoming and then winds 730 miles downward toward the ocean running through places such as the Browns Park and Dinosaur National Monument. Many people from all over the nation love the Green River because it carved out some of America’s most iconic canyons and is seen as one of the most beautiful waterways in the nation. The river is also valued as home to several threatened and endangered species, including the bonytail and humpback chub, the razorback sucker, and the Colorado pikeminnow.
Recently, serious debate unfolded over the fate of the Green River and Colorado’s ever increasing water deficit. A new study from the U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Reclamation indicates Colorado will have at least a nine percent decline in water flow by 2050. The study projected significant impacts on fish and fishing as well as negative impacts on other recreation. White water rafting, which brings in at least $4.2 million a year for local businesses, would be impacted particularly hard. While Colorado has allowed more than it is legally required to flow downstream, other states are already violating the 1922 Compact for the Lower Water Basin by taking more than their legal share of water from the river. Many politicians and water developers have put forward different ideas in recent years to deal with the water deficit, but one of the most controversial plans is constructing a pipeline to take water from the Green River.
Flaming Gorge Pipeline
The pipeline, proposed by Aaron Million, is known as the Flaming Gorge pipeline. The proposal calls for a 500 mile water pipeline to pump eighty-one billion gallons of water per year out of the Green River in Wyoming for use in Colorado, which amounts to approximately twenty to thirty percent of the river’s annual flow. At this time, the pipeline would cost between seven and nine billion dollars without including any costs to deal with the massive environmental impacts the pipeline would cause. The State of Colorado’s Water Conservation Board (“CWCB”) initiated a preliminary study on the pipeline, but the CWCB denied additional funding in January of 2013 for a subsequent, more intensive study.
The pipeline creates several concerns, one of which is how likely Utah and Wyoming will let the project go unchallenged despite the significant potential impact on their states. Additionally, the pipeline lacks substantial popular support in any of the three states it directly impacts. In fact, surveys of Colorado residents show that seventy-six percent of residents prefer a solution for the state’s water issues that focuses on using existing water more efficiently rather than building a pipeline. American Rivers, a non-profit seeking protection of the United States’ rivers and streams, listed the Green River as the second most endangered river in a 2012 national study, mostly because of the proposed Flaming Gorge pipeline.
In the face of the recent Bureau of Reclamation study and urgings from the public to look at conservation measures, the CWCB’s decision to stop funding the second study of Flaming Gorge pipeline may forecast trouble for the project. Some even see abandonment of the study as an implied rejection of the project. In the next few months, Colorado lawmakers will set a future course for the state’s water usage, which will impact generations of residents. Any measure these lawmakers choose will also set a tone for the rest of the region on dealing with this increasingly desperate water situation. Hopefully, Colorado chooses to set a tone of interstate cooperation that places conservation and smart water use above more environmentally questional proposals.
- Allen Best, When it comes to water in the West, is any idea too crazy?, The Denver Post, Mar. 3, 2013, http://www.denverpost.com/recommended/ci_22692365.
- Rachel Nuwer, It’s Not Too Late To Change the Course of the Vanishing Colorado River, Take Part, Feb. 11, 2013, http://www.takepart.com/article/2013/02/05/change-course-save-colorado-river.
- Jessie Thomas-Blate, Great News For The Green River!, American Rivers: The River Blog, Feb. 4, 2013, http://www.americanrivers.org/newsroom/blog/jtblate-20130204-great-news-for-the-green-river.html.
- Calvin Hazlewood, Letter to the Editor, Green River Needs Protecting, Casper Star Tribune, Feb. 3, 2013, http://trib.com/opinion/letters/green-river-needsprotecting/ article_2f72bdd8-417b-5b57-8540-9324ae9d17d3.html.
- Brett Prettyman, Flaming Gorge pipeline foes win a skirmish in long war, Salt Lake Tribune, Jan. 30, 2013,http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/news/5573472978/colorado-flaming-gorge-green.html.csp.
- Scott Willoughby, Scenery, solitude supplied at Browns Park National Wildlife Refuge, The Denver Post, Aug. 11, 2012, http://www.denverpost.com/outdoors/ci_21292769/ scenery-solitude-supplied-at-browns-park-national-wildlife.
- America’s Most Endangered Rivers 2012, American Rivers, http://www.americanrivers. org/assets/pdfs/mer-2012/2012-compiled.pdf.
- U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Reclamation, Reclamation Managing Water in the West: Colorado River Basin Water Supply and Demand Study, Executive Summary (2012), available at http://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/crbstudy/finalreport /Executive%20Summary/CRBS_Executive_Summary_FINAL.pdf.
Heading Photo Copyright Don Cload and licensed for reuse under the Creative Commons Licence